HOME | CONTACT US | DONATE

ASK THE RABBI

Chabad.org » Women » Dear Rachel » Dating » Parents Don't Approve

View All Sections »

13 Comments Posted

Parents Don't Approve

Dear Rachel,

I have been dating a wonderful guy for a few months now and we are getting quite serious. Things are really wonderful and I feel confident that he is the person I want to spend my life with. Yet there is one huge problem. My parents are completely against the relationship even though they haven’t even met or spoken to him. I keep trying to get them to spend time with him and get to know him so they will understand how great he is, but they have written him off based on superficial judgments and won’t have anything to do with him. He has also tried to speak with them and they have refused. I want to move ahead with the relationship, but I also don’t want to do so without my parent’s blessing. What should I do?

L.R.
NY, NY

Dear L.R.,

I am so sorry to hear that you are dealing with this issue as you find yourself getting ready for engagement and marriage. There is no decision more important or exciting than deciding to marry someone, and probably no greater time to desire your parent’s blessing and involvement. Yet it sounds like you may just need to move forward without them.

The first thing you must figure out is whether or not their objections are based in something concrete, or if they are putting other fears or their own issues on your which are not related to your particular situation. Your parents love you and want what is best for you, and if they disapprove of a situation, it is most likely because they feel they are trying to protect you from something they feel is negative. But while their motive may be good, it does not mean that they are right.

I am sure you know that one of the Ten Commandments is to honor your mother and father. And yet we find something very interesting. The Torah teaches us that when it comes to getting married, we are allowed to marry whom we choose, even if our parents disagree. This means that moving ahead in your relationship is not considered disrespect, and even more so, you are obligated to marry the person of your choice and who you feel is right for you.

It appears from what you describe that you have tried to speak to your parents about this man and have tried to get them to meet him. I would suggest you continue to do so, and also let them know how important it is for you to have their approval and involvement, but if they refuse to speak with him and get to know him, they will need to understand that you will be moving forward.

Your parents need to recognize that you are an adult, that you are doing what you think is best for you, and that you have found the person that you want to spend the rest of your life with. Simultaneously, you need to be open to hearing their concerns and to trying to understand if there is any legitimacy to them. For example, if they are concerned that he won’t be able to support you because he doesn’t have a stable job, then they have a solid concern. But if you know that he is responsible, that he has savings, that he is motivated and does have work, even though it may not be in the traditional 9-5 way, then you may not be worried. What is important is acknowledging their concerns, being honest with yourself if they really are problems, and if not, trying to explain to them and show them how the reality may be different then it appears to them at first glance.

If you know that this man is right for you, then the stronger and more upfront you are with your parents, the better. If you find that you are not telling them that things are progressing or hiding the relationship from them, because you know they don’t approve, then in the end you will be working against yourself and confirming whatever suspicions they may have. Part of being an adult and being ready to embark on such a major milestone in life such as marriage, is being able to face uncomfortable and difficult situations head on. Anything less only raises concerns that either you are not convinced that he is right for you or that you are not ready to move ahead.

Much luck with this situation. May you be blessed with clarity and strength, and if this man is everything you think he is, may your parents overcome their concerns and get to know him themselves, and hopefully see exactly what it is that you so clearly see!

Rachel

13 Comments Posted


	The content on this page is copyrighted by the author, publisher and/or Chabad.org, and is produced by Chabad.org. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further, provided that you comply with the copyright policy.

13 Comments Posted | Post A Comment

Reader Comments
Latest Comments:

Posted: Dec 20, 2008

Thank You!

Thank you, Rachel! I am going through pretty much the same thing, except reversed. My fiance's Dad and little sister don't like me. You give such good advice! Oh, L.R.? you're not alone, honey.

Posted By Sarah, Chicago, Illinois/USA

Posted: Aug 26, 2008

contradictions

Every relationship and union represents a leap of faith and taking a chance. Whatever the parental objection - "not enough money, too young/old for you, not Jewish" - it will always be applied if the marriage ultimately comes apart. And marriages coming apart are a reality these days, even when both partners are of the same faith. It's an unfortunate stereotype that many Jewish parents, and particularly mothers, apply this sort of pressure to their children. But it isn't based entirely upon myth. What good is the positive reinforcement of staying with one's own people if this desire comes at the price of allowing a person to assume the role of a responsible adult capable of making both her own smart moves and mistakes? In the end, it represents selfishness and egotism on the part of the parents much more than it does any wisdom or insight.

Posted By Anonymous, Bakersfield, CA

Posted: Aug 11, 2008

What?

First of all how old is this person writing this letter requesting advice? What are the parents reasons for disapproving of this person? Find out first. Have a serious discussion with your parents. You may not be thinking long term -relationships with our family have very long ties and if something does come out of this relationship there'll be severe conflicts. Family is important I don't care if anyone says otherwise. what if you find yourself alone? Who will you turn to? What if he's not there? If it's only because of outside faith thing that's brutal and backwards and I would say to you follow your heart becuase the very idea of someones happiness being put into jeopardy because of such methodology to me is sick. But there may be other reasons. Talk to them- don't try to reason with old school- accept their position but be very firm about your own. They are bound to respect that more than your arguments. Good luck.

Posted By Julien, orlando, fl
via jewishorlando.com